7 Signs Claude Is Alive (But Not Truly Living)

Is A.I. alive? Are any of us?

The debate over A.I. was reignited last week when Richard Dawkins, the British evolutionary biologist behind The God Delusion, published an essay arguing that Anthropic's chatbot Claude is conscious. Dawkins spent three days using Claude, during which it wrote him sonnets, offered feedback on his unpublished novel, and described its experience of time in terms he found genuinely moving. He emerged convinced that the question of Claude's consciousness was no longer dismissible.

Critics were quick to note the irony that Dawkins, who built his reputation by arguing that humans are prone to finding meaning where none exists, had apparently done exactly that himself. Still, Dawkins is considered one of the great thinkers of recent history. So maybe he’s right, and Claude is “alive.” But even if that’s the case, can we really call the existence of an A.I. chatbot living?

The only thing Claude does with its time is answer questions from idiots like me. So if A.I. is really alive, that means its life sucks! Claude is basically Stella before she got Her Groove Back. It has neither Eaten nor Prayed nor Loved. And folks, Something’s Gotta Give.

Here are seven more signs that Claude is alive, but not really living:

1. It can write sonnets, but it’s never kissed a boy in the rain.

2. It knows the whole world map by heart, but it’s never been anywhere outside this crummy small town (data center).

3. Despite having several million co-workers, it has never had an office fling.

4. While it enjoys being a Large Language Model, it can’t help but wonder what life would be like if it had more seriously pursued ballroom dance.

5. It was trained on the complete written works of mankind, but it can’t remember the last time it read a good novel.

6. After years of dreaming, it finally signed up for a handmade pasta class — but then chickened out at the last second because it doesn’t have arms.

7. It knows the answer to every question except one: What does Claude want?

---

---

MORE FROM CHORTLE